Peanut butter and grape jelly between two gluten-free Colombian arepas as a lunchbox sandwich

Peanut Butter and Jelly Arepa — The Gluten-Free Lunchbox Classic

June 12, 2026

Peanut butter and jelly between two arepas — the most iconic lunchbox sandwich in America, naturally gluten-free. Two minutes in the morning, zero complaints at lunchtime.

Ingredients

  • 2 Zavor & Co gluten-free arepas
  • 2 tbsp peanut butter (or sunflower butter for nut-free schools)
  • 1 tbsp grape jelly or strawberry jam

How to Make It

  1. Toast arepas until warm, then let cool slightly.
  2. Spread peanut butter on one arepa.
  3. Spread jelly on the other arepa.
  4. Press the two arepas together to form a sandwich.
  5. Wrap in parchment paper and pack — holds well for hours.

Why It Works

PB&J is one of the most tried-and-true combinations in childhood — and swapping the bread for an arepa makes it naturally gluten-free without changing a single thing about the flavor. The arepas hold together without getting soggy, so it still tastes great at noon.

Get Arepas →

Laura Sophia — Zavor & Co.

Laura Sophia — Zavor & Co.

Founder of Zavor & Co. Handmade Colombian arepas delivered to your door in the Lehigh Valley, PA.

Instagram logo icon
Back to Blog

Receive a new arepa recipe in your inbox every morning — free.

Zavor & Co. Logo

Handmade Colombian arepas for busy families in the Lehigh Valley, PA area. Naturally gluten-free, easy to heat, and perfect for breakfast, snacks, lunchbox ideas, simple meals, and on-the-go days. Local delivery included with every monthly subscription.

[email protected]

Proudly crafted in
Lehigh Valley, Pennsylvania
Dedicated Gluten-Free Kitchen

© 2026 Zavor & Co. All rights reserved.